| She comes by herself, Brings us our gifts | 
| It’s hard to tell, She leaves so swift | 
| She don’t love you, She don’t love me | 
| Whoever she loves, That man must be free | 
| I don’t know, Maybe you do | 
| What she be thinking, When she looks at you | 
| She sits on the floor, Looks at the movie | 
| She gets high too, This girl is groovy | 
| I don’t wanna, make you run | 
| From all of us, We just have fun | 
| And we touch ya, but you don’t let us fuck ya | 
| She has good intentions, It’s obvious to see | 
| But who is this girl, Why can’t we see | 
| What she would do, Behind closed doors | 
| With you or with me | 
| Why can’t we see! | 
| Hook | 
| Sarah, you like to keep me wondering | 
| Sarah, you know you keep us wondering, | 
| She’s sexy as she sounds | 
| With her pretty little mouth | 
| And she likes to help around | 
| With little things in the house | 
| I wanna do things to her mouth | 
| She swear that ain’t what she bout | 
| I start to doubt, I start to figure her out | 
| Sometimes I get to see your sister | 
| And I touched her, but I… I didn’t get to fuck her, (or kiss her) | 
| Don’t you know that we talk about you | 
| Me and my brothers want a… a piece of you | 
| Whoa, pretty brown hair, how long do you plan on staying here | 
| She brought us drinks and food, She ain’t never rude | 
| Can we share this woman, It would be wrong to keep her | 
| Tell me why she wouldn’t, Can’t she see that we need her | 
| Hook | 
| Sarah, you like to keep me wondering | 
| Sarah, you know you keep us wondering |